So. Cal. Winery Review
  • Home
  • About
  • Wineries
  • Gadgets
  • Tasting Menus
  • WINERY NEWS
  • Home
  • About
  • Wineries
  • Gadgets
  • Tasting Menus
  • WINERY NEWS
• WINE wine Wine wINE•

SOUTHERN CALIFORNIA WINERY REVIEW

Picture
Introduction
​
Welcome to Southern California Winery Review!  I started this website in late 2017 because I kept finding really bad wineries getting rave reviews, while some very, very good wineries were totally ignored.  So, I've spent quite a bit of time visiting wineries in Southern California (over 60).  Of these I've found about 40 pretty good wineries, certainly worth my taking the time to write them up.  I know what you are thinking -- it's a dirty job, but someone has to do it....  These are summarized in the Wineries section of this website. 
Now wineries in Southern California  are rapidly becoming the centers of social activities.  Not just for special events (weddings and the like), but as a place to go on weekends with friends, to enjoy good wine (ok, that's pretty obvious), good food, and even good entertainment.  While most wineries have some sort of wine club, no two are run the same.  Some wineries have restaurants.  Some have entertainment on weekends.  Some even have hotels.   So I have included information on all of this, both in the Wineries section and in the Winery News section.
If you are looking for specific varietals, you can find long lists at the beginning of the About section.  Not just what varietals are available in Southern California, but which wineries are offering them.  The About section also includes info on wine storage, corks, the Sommelier test, how to cool your wine to proper serving temperature, and other little tidbits.

I am not really qualified to review the wines themselves, though I will tell you what I like and maybe even what I don't like.  However, I have a wine collector (now a Level 1 Sommelier) who will provide us some insights into particular wines.  One word of warning:  both he and I are red wine enthusiasts....   Wine quality determines which wineries I review, though I also pay attention to the wine tasting room, personnel, location, view, et al.   I should add that I am very much a red wine enthusiast....
And speaking of red wine, I shall now expound on my pet peeve -- namely, drinking red wine at "room temperature"!  Red wine should be stored and drunk at a temperature below 65 F.  If you don't believe me, I suggest you run a little experiment -- I like experiments, in fact I'm a retired experimental physicist.  Pour red wine into two glasses in a warm room.  Chill one to below 65 F (put it in the fridge for about 20 minutes) and let the other glass warm up.  Then taste them both.... 
See picture below for recommended drinking temperatures.  By the way, what you see in the picture is the back of a wine temperature gauge, one of many wine-related paraphenalia in the Gadgets section.
IMPORTANT NOTE:  I HAVE ADDED LINKS FROM THE WINERIES​ PAGE TO THE SPECIFIC WINERY REVIEW.  Oh, at the end of each post is a small Facebook Like box....  Would really like a lot of likes....

Picture
Red wine should be aerated, i.e., allowed to breath.  You can buy a simple aerator that will do the job, twirl the wine in the glass, or just let the wine sit for  awhile before drinking.  Of course, if the room is warm, see above....
One question you may be asking yourself:  why should I buy wine from a winery rather than Cosco, a supermarket, or a wine shop?  Well, for one thing, if you visit the winery you taste the wine before you buy it.  Then there is the fact that Cosco and the supermarkets don't store the wine properly, so even if you get a good wine the first time the next bottle you buy might not be as good.  That assumes they still carry it and you can remember what it was you bought in the first place.
But there is another reason -- wineries in Southern California make varietals that you are unlikely to find at Costco or a supermarket.  I list  a whole batch of white and red varietals I've tasted at the wineries I've reviewed.  Costco only carries around 15 red varietals.  You won't find three of my favorite wines:  LaGrein, Negroamaro and Montipulciano.  To make it easier to find a winery offering your favorite varietal, the wine varietal wine lists are now in the Wineries section .
Picture
 NEWS FLASH:  Worried about the brown-outs ruining your wine?  Well, Chateau 55 has added a generator so your wine will always stay coo.  Mention our name and get the first month of storage free and a 5% discount for the next 11 months storage.  To check them out  click the link below. 
Link to Chateau 55 Website
33% Discount!  Save $20 on a $59.99 Priority Wine Pass by using the link below and entering the code scwr.
Link to Priority Wine Pass

The Latest Blog
Dudes!  Read all about Jim and Ed's Excellent Adventure -- and South Coast Winery!
Site News​​
  •  I've deleted the About Red Wines and About White Wines from the About section, with the listing now in the Wineries section.
  • With reviews now coming in from Doc Ed on Oregon wineries, I've added a listing of reviewed Oregon wineries in the Wineries section, after the extensive So Cal winery listing.​
About Section Contents
The About section is getting a bit crowded, so I thought it might be worthwhile to list the contents, as follows:
  1. About Sommeliers
  2. About Chilling Wine
  3. About Southern California Wineries
  4. About the Lum Eisensan/San Diego Wine Competition
  5. About Corks
  6. About Wine Clubs
  7. About Wine Storage
  8. About Balsamic Vinegar

Napa

11/14/2018

0 Comments

 
We’ve just returned from a great four-day wine tasting jaunt with friends to the Napa wine making region, visiting nine wineries.  Way back in 1978 we lived for a short time in Berkeley.  Touring the wineries in Napa was one of our favorite past times.  We would stop first at Robert Mondavi, take the winery tour (you had to take the winery tour), taste their wines, then move on to our next stop, Beaulieu Vineyards (BV).  Lunch would be had at a small winery with a great deli up the road from BV, where we would buy some cheese, bread and wine and have a picnic in their front picnic ground.  Often, we would go from there to Louis Martini, and sometimes even go as far as Christian Brothers.  With the exception of my visit to Stag’s Leap a couple of years ago, we hadn’t been back until last Friday.  During this trip we revisited two of the wineries we had visited years ago, as well as Stag’s Leap.  Everything has changed.
In those early days tasting was free.  Now they charge you $40-45 per person.  There weren’t many wineries – now there are too many to count.  Their wines had only recently been “discovered” re: the wine tasting held in Paris in 1976 – which, by the way, was won by Stag’s Leap (not to be confused with Stags’ Leap) as shown in the documents below -- so wine prices were pretty reasonable.  The term “tourist trap” is probably the closest fit for Napa today.  For those of you who are not familiar with the Paris wine tasting, check out the book “Judgement of Paris” by George Taber or go see the move “Bottle Shock”.
Picture
Picture
​In the paragraphs that follow I will expound on each winery in the order that we visited them.  I will hold off pictures until the end.  I should add that Napa is all about Cabernet Sauvignon.  It is the basis for the great Bordeaux reds, and, since the climate in Napa is very similar to that in Bordeaux, it is a natural direction to go.  Of course, it helps that they can sell their Cabernets for >$100 per bottle.  The rest of their red wine varietals range from the “undrinkable” to the “not so bad”.  Not to say that we didn’t dump more than a few tastes of Cabernet…
Oh, from the perspective of this web site, I cannot recommend joining any of the wine clubs in Napa.  Napa is too far away to take advantage of the free wine tasting or to participate in their other activities.  Their wines are priced for the tourist trade, i.e., way overpriced.  Then there is the fact noted above that Napa is all about Cabernet Sauvignon.
We began our tour on Friday…
V. Sattui
If you paid attention to my opening paragraph, you will have noticed that I did not name the winery that we stopped at for lunch back in 1978.  In truth, we did not remember the name – it was just coincidence that it wound up as our first stop on the tour.
The deli has gotten much bigger, the food better, they’ve added a second picnic ground, and even an underground barrel room.  Back then they didn’t offer wine tasting.  Now you can taste their wines, but only at their wine tasting bar.  If you want wine with your food you have to buy a bottle.  About the only winery we visited with reasonable prices on wine tasting ($20) and wines.  As for the quality of the wines – did I mention that they have great food?
Jessup Cellars
I’m not sure if we had done our homework, we would have stopped at Jessup Cellars since the wine tasting was not at the winery but in town.  They own only a small plot of land, and only grow Sauvignon Blanc grapes.  Now, if you are in the market to purchase very unique, original paintings, this is the place to go.  Jessup Cellars might not be the best place for wine tasting, but it is worth visiting just for the art.
Now on to Saturday…
Charles Krug
Our visit to Charles Krug was, in my opinion, the highlight of our trip.  We sat at a very comfortable table and got to taste one white wine and four excellent Cabernet Sauvignon variations, all served at the proper temperature.  It proved to be the only winery that made it a point to do so.  All of the rest seemed content to serve their $100+ wines at well above optimum temperature.  This I cannot understand.  They work so hard to get you to buy their wines, put huge amounts of money in the tasting rooms, but won’t spend an extra penny to present the wines at their best.
Now after pontificating on my pet peeve it is back to Charles Krug.  For a few dollars more than the $45 tasting fee, we had some outstanding cheese and other goodies to go with the wine.  Great facility, great people, great wine, great food – in other words, they spoiled it for the other wineries we were to visit on the trip.  There was a bit of pressure to join their wine club, with the offer to waive our tasting fees.  Eventually we did join as a group, with the plan being for each of the couples to wind up with two bottles of their great Cabernets at the club price and saving the $45 tasting fee.
Round Pond
A wonderful facility, we were again seated for the tasting.  The servers kept changing on us, but all were very nice and seemed to work well together.  One nice feature is that they had a glass for each taste.  However, I sort of expected more than three tastes, and only two reds, both very expensive Cabernets, for $40.  Having just tasted four $100+ reds for $45 at Charles Krug, this did not go over well.  I noted that they had non-Cabernet reds on their price list, so I asked about tasting them.  I never got an answer.
Castello di Amorosa
After Round Pond, we drove up to Callistoga to visit the castle.  Yes, Castello di Amorosa actually has a castle on its winery.  $30 gets you admission into the castle and wine tasting ($20 for children with grape juice tasting).  We were told at the admission booth that the standard tasting was mostly sweet wines, that the reds would require upgrade to premium level for another $15.  That was a lie – the normal level had many red wines, and the premium level only added three. But the Castle is something else again.
Sunday…
Stag’s Leap
Stag’s Leap Wine Cellars – not to be confused with Stags’ Leap Winery – was our first stop of the day, and once again a bit of a spoiler.  After all, this is the winery that produced the red wine that won the Paris wine tasting event, their Cabernet Sauvignon SLV.  We had to stand up for tasting at this winery, but otherwise a very nice presentation of some very good wines.  Nominally, it’s $45 for four tastes.  Our server, who probably sells time-shares in her spare time, was not going to let us get away with tasting just their fantastic Chardonnay, or their three top Cabernet – Fay, SLV, and Cask 23 – which, by the way, sell for $69, $150, $175, and $295, respectively.  When we didn’t move on buying any of the wines we had just tasted, she pulled out other wines.  I wound up tasting six wines, including their Artemis Cabernet Sauvignon.  Now for an aside.
You can call a wine a varietal if 75% of the wine is made from the varietal grape.  Many of the wine makers in Napa insist that their Cabernet Sauvignon be pure – made from 100% Cabernet Sauvignon grapes.  We saw this with Charles Krug, and Stag’s Leap main wines – SLV, Fay, and Cask 23.  The French do not see it that way – their Cabernet Sauvignon is usually a blend, with small amounts of Merlot or other grape varieties added.  According to Doc Ed, this is important – it gives the wine a better finish.  So why raise this issue here?  Well, Stag’s Leap Artemis is just such a wine – an “impure” Cabernet Sauvignon.  But it is really good – and only $69 per bottle – so we bought two bottles and we got comped for the tasting.
Silverado
As noted above, the Stag’s Leap people were not at all stingy with their wine, so we were a bit out of it for our visit to Silverado.  They had a Sicilian wagon out front of their very lovely facility, so I assumed that they made some Italian varietals.  Alas, that was not to be.  We were actually too large a group for walk-ins, but they were kind enough to allow us to remain and taste their wines.  While they didn’t have any Italian wines, they did have two pretty good non-Cabernet reds – a Cabernet Franc and a Malbec.  Given that these are two of my least favorable red varietals, my saying that they were pretty good is significant.
Auburn James
We ended the day at Auburn James.  Now this is a very small winery that does not grow any grapes at all.  None.  They buy grapes and make them into wine.  It being a small winery, we had a Ramona-like experience, sitting down enjoying their wine along with the assistant wine maker, who also has a share in the company.  Their purported niche is to follow the French concept of blending their Cabernet Sauvignon grapes – and to do so in the true French tradition, without added sulfites.  We had a great time sitting around trying this and that, and, fortunately, members of our party bought a couple of bottles of their wine.
Monday…
Robert Mondavi
We saved the best-known winery in Napa, Robert Mondavi, for last.  OK, we didn’t actually plan on visiting them, just had some extra time on our hands…  Whatever, it was worth the visit.  The wine tasting was a flight-type affair where they pour four wines and you get to parallel taste them.  They let us take the wines outside, so it was a really good experience.
At this point you are probably asking one important question:  How do the wines in Southern California stack up against the wines out of Napa?  In my very uninformed opinion, with the one very notable exception, the red wines produced in Southern California are superior to the Napa wines, and far more affordable.  The notable exception:  Cabernet Sauvignon.  Which, of course, makes perfect sense.  Napa’s climate is ideal for Cabernet Sauvignon, but it is just too hot down here for that grape.  Oh, and neither region can make a decent Pinot Noir…
V. Sattui Pictures
Picture
Picture
Picture
Picture
Picture
Picture
Picture
​Charles Krug pictures
Picture
Picture
Picture
Picture
Picture
Round Pond pictures
Picture
Picture
Picture
Picture
Picture
Castello di Amorosa pictures
Picture
Picture
Picture
Picture
Picture
Picture
​Stag's Leap pictures
Picture
Picture
Picture
Picture
Picture
​Silverado pictures
Picture
Picture
Picture
Picture
Picture
Auburn James pictures
Picture
Picture
​Robert Mondavi pictures
Picture
Picture
Picture
Picture
Picture
0 Comments

    Jim Treglio

    retired physicist and wine lover

    Archives

    April 2021
    March 2021
    February 2021
    January 2021
    December 2020
    November 2020
    October 2020
    September 2020
    August 2020
    July 2020
    June 2020
    May 2020
    April 2020
    March 2020
    February 2020
    January 2020
    December 2019
    November 2019
    October 2019
    September 2019
    August 2019
    July 2019
    June 2019
    May 2019
    April 2019
    March 2019
    February 2019
    January 2019
    December 2018
    November 2018
    October 2018
    September 2018
    August 2018
    July 2018
    June 2018
    May 2018
    April 2018
    March 2018
    February 2018
    January 2018
    December 2017

    Categories

    All

    RSS Feed

Powered by Create your own unique website with customizable templates.